Star performer ends six-month winless run for Borders racehorse trainer Gary Rutherford

Simple Star lived up to the second half of his name with a first-placed finish at Musselburgh Racecourse yesterday, September 30, for Camptown trainer Gary Rutherford.

That win at 4-1, with Sam James as jockey, came in the last of the meeting’s seven races, the 5.08pm Join Racing TV Now Handicap over a mile and almost six furlongs.

Jockey Sam James on Simple Star, trained at Camptown by Gary Rutherford, at Musselburgh Racecourse last Wednesday (Photo: Alan Raeburn/Musselburgh Races)placeholder image
Jockey Sam James on Simple Star, trained at Camptown by Gary Rutherford, at Musselburgh Racecourse last Wednesday (Photo: Alan Raeburn/Musselburgh Races)

The eight-year-old bay gelding finished a length and a quarter in front of Oliver Stammers on Riddikulus, trained by Grant Tuer in North Yorkshire, to claim that concluding race’s top prize of £3,664.

That was Simple Star’s first win in five rides since arriving at Rutherford’s yard in July, after previously being trained in Cumbria by Dianne Sayer, and eighth all together since 2021, the last one prior also having been at Musselburgh with James in the saddle, in August 2025.

Jockey Sam James, third from right, with Simple Star, trained at Camptown by Gary Rutherford, far right, at Musselburgh Racecourse last Wednesday (Photo: Alan Raeburn/Musselburgh Races)placeholder image
Jockey Sam James, third from right, with Simple Star, trained at Camptown by Gary Rutherford, far right, at Musselburgh Racecourse last Wednesday (Photo: Alan Raeburn/Musselburgh Races)

It ended a winless run for Rutherford stretching back 62 races and just short of six months, his last first-placed finish before that having been with Looking Splendid at Kelso, with Dylan Johnston as jockey, at the beginning of April.

Simple Star was one of two Borders-trained horses in a field of six for the meeting’s finale, the other, finishing last, being 7-4 favourite Falaise Blanc, entered by Selkirk’s Katie Scott and ridden by Jason Hart, Hart being one of two Hawick jockeys competing, along with Rhys Elliott, a fourth-placed finisher on Togeather Forever for Jim Goldie’s East Renfrewshire stables.

Rutherford was the Borders’ only winner at the East Lothian track, the nearest otherwise being Hart’s third – and last – place on another of Scott’s horses, Just for Monty, in the day’s opening race, the 1.38pm British EBF Novice Stakes, won by Kevin Stott on North Yorkshire trainer Kevin Ryan’s Sable Noir.

News you can trust since 1855
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice