Deja vu as Gala Fairydean Rovers hit by third 3-2 loss to Cumbernauld Colts on spin in cup final

This season’s Scottish Lowland Football League Cup final in Bo’ness, near Falkirk, on Sunday might have been Gala Fairydean Rovers’ first in their 13-year history but the 3-2 scoreline inflicted on them by Cumbernauld Colts was all too familiar.

That was the two teams’ third meeting of this term and all three have gone the same way, with manager Martin Scott’s Borderers ending up on the wrong end of a five-goal scoreline after going in front against opposite number John Doyle’s colts.

Josh Mulgrew in action for Gala Fairydean Rovers during their 3-2 loss to Cumbernauld Colts in 2026’s Scottish Lowland Football League Cup final at Newtown Park in Bo’ness on Sunday (Photo: Gala Fairydean Rovers)placeholder image
Josh Mulgrew in action for Gala Fairydean Rovers during their 3-2 loss to Cumbernauld Colts in 2026’s Scottish Lowland Football League Cup final at Newtown Park in Bo’ness on Sunday (Photo: Gala Fairydean Rovers)

Rovers’ scorers past opposition goalkeeper Harry Broun at Newtown Park at the weekend were Liam Fagan on 35 minutes and Jamie Semple on 81, with Josh Farquhar, Danny Hatfield and Aiden McLaughlin netting the other way beyond Reece Murray on 52, 53 and three minutes into stoppage time respectively, their last goal being McLaughlin’s first for the club.

That third 3-2 loss to the North Lanarkshire outfit on the bounce followed ones on league duty at home in Galashiels eight days earlier, with that day’s match-winning goal also arriving three minutes after full-time, and on the road at Broadwood Stadium last October.

Jamie Semple in possession for Gala Fairydean Rovers during their 3-2 loss to Cumbernauld Colts in 2026’s Scottish Lowland Football League Cup final at Newtown Park in Bo’ness on Sunday (Photo: Gala Fairydean Rovers)placeholder image
Jamie Semple in possession for Gala Fairydean Rovers during their 3-2 loss to Cumbernauld Colts in 2026’s Scottish Lowland Football League Cup final at Newtown Park in Bo’ness on Sunday (Photo: Gala Fairydean Rovers)

Netting for Fairydean the weekend before were Jamie McMurdo from the penalty spot on 34 minutes and Clark Bexfield on 65, with Carrick McEvoy on target for Colts on seven, followed by Thomas Horn on 85 and Danny Hatfield on 93.

Semple and Jared Lyons got Gala’s goals in Cumbernauld five months ago, on 45 minutes and 58, with Josh Jack replying on four and 68 and Farquhar on 71.

Sunday’s cup final was Rovers’ third in three years, the previous two both having been in Midlothian.

The first of them was a 3-1 East of Scotland Qualifying Cup loss to Linlithgow Rose at Penicuik in 2022 and the second was a 4-3 East of Scotland Cup penalty shootout win against the same adversaries at Rosewell in 2023 after ending open play level at 2-2.

Gala Fairydean Rovers players celebrating scoring during their 3-2 loss to Cumbernauld Colts in 2026’s Scottish Lowland Football League Cup final at Newtown Park in Bo’ness on Sunday (Photo: Gala Fairydean Rovers)placeholder image
Gala Fairydean Rovers players celebrating scoring during their 3-2 loss to Cumbernauld Colts in 2026’s Scottish Lowland Football League Cup final at Newtown Park in Bo’ness on Sunday (Photo: Gala Fairydean Rovers)

The former was Rovers’ first final since the creation of their current incarnation by merging Gala Fairydean and Gala Rovers in 2013 and the latter was their first trophy win in any form since Fairydean claimed the qualifying cup in 1995 and their amateur opposite numbers chalked up a Beveridge Cup and Dudley Cup double in 2013.

Colts’ league cup final win was their first since one by 3-1 versus Selkirk in 2018 at Rovers’ Netherdale Stadium home ground.

Rovers made it to this year’s final via wins by 2-1 against Gretna 2008 in January’s first round, 2-0 versus table-toppers Bonnyrigg Rose Athletic in February’s quarter-finals and 2-1 against Tranent in the last four earlier this month.

Sunday’s defeat was Rovers’ second at Newtown Park in the space of four months after losing a Scottish Lowland Football League fixture against Bo’ness United there by 4-0 in November.

Gala Fairydean Rovers manager Martin Scott watching his side losing 3-2 to Cumbernauld Colts in 2026’s Scottish Lowland Football League Cup final at Newtown Park in Bo’ness on Sunday (Photo: Gala Fairydean Rovers)placeholder image
Gala Fairydean Rovers manager Martin Scott watching his side losing 3-2 to Cumbernauld Colts in 2026’s Scottish Lowland Football League Cup final at Newtown Park in Bo’ness on Sunday (Photo: Gala Fairydean Rovers)

Making up their starting line-up, captained by Danny Galbraith, were Murray in goal, Fagan, Arnault Kasa, Gregor Lamb, Keaghan Jacobs, Lewis Hall, Semple, Che Reilly, Ethan Dougal and Joe Wylie.

Lyons took over from Fagan on 89 minutes and Owen Calder from Kasa, McMurdo from Wylie and Josh Mulgrew from Hall on 68.

Fairydean’s five-match run-in to the end of this season begins with two away fixtures in four days, at fourth-placed Tranent this Wednesday and Edinburgh’s 14th-placed Civil Service Strollers on Saturday, with kick-offs at 7.45pm and 3pm respectively.

They go into those games sitting 13th in the table, on 32 points from 29 fixtures.

News you can trust since 1855
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice