Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Wind farms could mean red in sky at night for Borders

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 19 November 2009
WHILE Galloway Forest Park is celebrating its official confirmation as the first Dark Sky Park in the UK, there are concerns that in the Borders plans for more wind farms could see increased light pollution, writes Mark Entwistle.
Last week, Galloway Forest Park became only the fourth Dark Sky Park in the world and the first outside of the United States after the International Dark Sky Association confirmed Galloway as one of the best places for stargazing in the world.

Lighting experts were brought in to ensure the skies above the forest park were pitch black at night and the organisers of Galloway’s bid hope the award will boost tourism in south-west Scotland.

But dark skies, or the increasing lack of them, was also the subject of concern in the Borders this week when it emerged that if plans for 12 massive wind turbines proposed for a site on Minchmoor near Walkerburn get the go-ahead, defence officials want red aviation lighting on top of the structures.

The Ministry of Defence has informed Scottish Borders Council planning department that it has no objection to the application from Swedish energy giant Vattenfall for the Minchmoor site. But it wants red aviation lighting fitted to the most practical point as high up as possible on the 107m-tall structures if the application is approved.

All the lights bar one would measure 25 candela in brightness with the exception of the southern-most turbine, which would have to be fitted with a 200-candela light. This is because this turbine would be located very close to the entry to the Selkirk/Moffat Valley one-way system used by military aircraft.

As for a similar proposal at Whitton, near Morebattle – also from Vattenfall – the MoD has submitted a holding objection for the site as it is within the statutory safeguarded area for the seismological recording station at Eskdalemuir. But if the developer can overcome this objection, the MoD says it would then ask that these turbines are also fitted with aviation lighting.

Commenting on the issue, a Walkerburn resident told TheSouthern: “This would just be further industrialisation of Minchmoor.”

Vattenfall is Europe’s fifth largest electricity generator and the largest heat generator from a mix of hydroelectric power mainly located in northern Sweden, nuclear power at two plants in Sweden and at two plants in Germany, and gas and coal-based power in Germany and Poland.

Scottish Borders councillor Bill Herd, whose ward includes Walkerburn, says when it comes to such applications, every detail is considered.

“These lights would probably be flashing lights and that is something we would have to think about. But that would just be one aspect of the planning application that needs to be considered,” said Councillor Herd.

“The Ministry of Defence has a legitimate right to make such a request as it has a responsibility to ensure the safety of its personnel.

Page 1 of 2

  • Last Updated: 18 November 2009 12:04 PM
  • Source: Southern Reporter
  • Location: Scotland
 
Prev
1
Next
1

simon blackwood,

Nr Hawick 22/11/2009 12:55:59
Common sense and aesthetic considerations are seemingly at the end of the queue when it comes to wind turbines. The MOD has decided or been told that they are the saviours of the planet as they have also for NATO training exercises rented out in the Scottish Borders air space.
Borderers have put up with the noise and terrifying sudden appearance of fighter jets for many years but the sheer joy of returning home over the Carter Bar from the South to be greeted by almost total darkness may now be a thing of the past.
It would be novel if the turbines had to generate their own electricity for these illuminations - during times of high pressure on those crystal clear winter evenings we would then enjoy no light pollution and no noise either as there would be no wind!
These are exteremely large, ugly intrusions into any landscape with or without flashing lights so maybe the next step is to attach sirens to them to scare away the eagles at Minchmoor when they start up?
2

Icebreaker,

newbridge 22/11/2009 18:44:52
How sad,surely only tidal or wave power can supply us
with constant electrical energy.
3

D Armstrong,

22/11/2009 22:25:18
So because townies feel guilty over global warming, the borders is now forced to have their landscape scarred.
4

ten pound tourist,

australia 26/11/2009 09:35:58
we have dark skies ad light skies, there are more dark than light, I agree as the populations increase then dark skies dissapear. Our population in Australia will never be as great as the northern hemisphere so we continue to enjoy starry starry nights
Prev
1
Next

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.